Pirates and Privateers
The History of Maritime
Piracy
Cindy Vallar, Editor
& Reviewer
P.O. Box 425,
Keller, TX 76244-0425
   
Books for Adults ~ Historical
Fiction: Pirates & Privateers
If the Tide Turns
The Determined

If the Tide Turns
by Rachel Rueckert
Kensington, 2024, ISBN 978-1-4967-4754-9, US $15.26
Available in various formats
    
The girl just
dove off the pier right before his eyes.
She doesn’t sink right away; she ventures
farther afield until her strength gives
out. That’s when he jumps in and rescues
her.
Maria Brown (also known as Goody or
Mehitable) just wants to learn to swim.
She’s been teaching herself, but those
lessons can only go so far. Swimming
allows a sense a freedom, something which
is nearing an end. At seventeen, she
should be married, but she’s learned that
resisting is futile. Sooner or later, she
will have to marry John Hallett and her
life will no longer be her own.
Samuel Bellamy should be looking for a job
now that the war has ended and the Royal
Navy has released him from service. But
jobs on Cape Cod are few and there’s
something about the beautiful girl he
saves that speaks to him. It’s as if they
are kindred souls. To see her again, he
offers to give her swimming lessons.
Despite the risk to her reputation, Maria
takes him up on his offer. The time they
spend together is precious, and Sam’s
unique way of looking at life stirs
long-buried ideas within her. Still, the
clock ticks closer to the inevitable
period when their paths will diverge. She
already knows her future, or at least she
thinks she does. For Sam, he’s offered a
chance to acquire riches enough to
convince Maria’s father that he deserves
to wed Maria instead of the prosperous and
influential Hallett. Waiting in the wings,
however, is Maria’s mother. She’s
determined that her daughter will follow a
straight and righteous path, one where
Maria will not have to endure what she
has. Before long, choices are made – ones
that cannot be undone – and their paths
are forever altered in ways neither
expects.
Rueckert masterfully whisks together
historical facts with legend and lore to
create a spellbinding and realistic tale
that breathes new life into Maria Hallett
and Sam Bellamy. Along the way, we
experience the cruelties and hardships of
social life on Cape Cod, as well as the
desperateness that drives people toward
alternatives they might never have pursued
otherwise. If the Tide Turns takes
place between 1715 and 1717, and readers
meet real life pirates such as Paulsgrave
Williams, Henry Jennings, Benjamin
Hornigold, Edward Teach, John Julian, and
John King (the youngest known pirate).
Time and again, the story transports
readers with its you-are-there sensation.
Even if you know the story of Sam and
Maria, Rueckert will make you think again.
Unexpected twists and harsh realities are
deftly entwined with hope and aspirations
to create a story of enduring love.
Review Copyright ©2024 Cindy Vallar


The Determined
by Rachel Rueckert
Kensington, February 2026, ISBN
978-1-4967-4756-3, US $9.99
Available in various formats
    
In February 1721,
Anne Bonny sits in a gaol in
Spanish Town on the isle of
Jamaica. She awaits the birth
of her child, as well as the
hangman’s noose, for her
pregnancy is all that stays
her execution. Since her
capture, the days have passed
in monotony, without
companionship and without
anything to mark one day from
another. On this particular
day, that changes – a
gentleman wearing a tricorn
with an ostrich feather comes
to visit. He wishes to write
her story to add to his
forthcoming collection that he
hopes will be a bestseller.
His name is Captain Charles
Johnson. Anne is reticent to
share her story – what
business is it to others – but
she asks for two boons. One is
paper and ink to write
letters. The second is for
word of Mary and a doctor to
tend to her ailing friend.
Interwoven through the
chapters set in 1721 are the
stories of the two most
notorious female pirates of
the golden age of piracy.
Anne’s begins in 1705 in
Kinsale, Ireland, where she is
the illegitimate daughter of a
lawyer from a well-to-do
family and a servant woman.
Social mores and debts drive
them from Ireland and
eventually, they land in
Charlestown, South Carolina.
From there, Anne explains the
circumstances of how she meets
James Bonny and the
unfortunate circumstances that
surround her arrival in New
Providence and her run-in with
Calico Jack Rackham.
Mary, too, is pregnant, but
her health is tenuous and the
odds are about even as to
whether the fever or the
hangman will claim her. Her
tale begins a decade before
Anne’s in London, England,
where Mary is known as Mark
Read and she has no idea that
she is a girl. The ruse is
staged by her mother to keep
them both alive, but the day
soon comes when Mary learns
the truth. Life isn’t fair to
women, and for them to
continue to survive, Mom must
separate from her and Mark
must continue to make “his”
way, this time as an
apprentice to a ship’s captain
who once was acquainted with
her father. World events
eventually disrupt their
lives, and if Mark wishes to
advance and gain enough money
to search for “his” mother, he
needs a new vocation. He joins
the cavalry, where a Flemish
officer makes Mark’s
acquaintance. What follows is
a love story that eventually
allows Mark to become Mary
once again, until tragedy
forces her to make new choices
that lead her to the Caribbean
where she eventually crosses
paths with Anne Bonny.
Using Johnson’s account of the
lives of these notorious
women, Rueckert has crafted a
compelling and totally
believable tale that fills in
all the blanks left by
Johnson. I have always been
drawn more to Mary Read than
Anne Bonny, and Rueckert’s
depiction of the two women
helped me understand why this
is. Her words paint visual
imagery that is dynamic and
three-dimensional, and they
depict two very different
women whose friendship and
living in a male-dominated
world bring them together to
live and survive. Her research
is spot-on and seamlessly
woven into the story in ways
that make it impossible to
separate fact from fiction,
although Rueckert does
elaborate on this in her
afterword.
Over the years, I’ve reviewed
numerous books about Anne
Bonny and Mary Read, but only
a few have touched my heart
and stayed with me long after
I finish reading. The
Determined is one of
those tales. It is as much a
treasure as James L. Nelson’s
The Only Life That Mattered
and N. C. Schell’s The
Ballade of Mary Reede.
Review
Copyright ©2025 Cindy Vallar

Click to contact me
Background image compliments
of Anke's Graphics |