Cindy Vallar, Editor & Reviewer
P.O. Box 425, Keller, TX 76244-0425
Books for Adults - Nonfiction
Internationally recognized as an expert on maritime piracy, Murphy analyzes Somalia and how its waters came to be the most prolific region of pirates today. He also compares this evolution with the Barbary corsairs in Northern Africa, who threatened Mediterranean ships and seamen from the Middle Ages into the nineteenth century.
Many volumes on Somali piracy focus only on that and fail to examine how historical events impacted the people and culture. Murphy provides a comprehensive examination through twenty-eight chapters. Also included are a list of abbreviations, map, notes, and an index.
In the early 1990s, the International Maritime Bureau designated the waters off Somalia as one of the most pirate infested in the world. Many scholars blame this on the country being a “failed state,” yet that alone cannot be the cause of piracy as Murphy shows in his comparison to piracy in Indonesia. He then lists what common bonds piracy-prone areas share before returning to how piracy evolved into its current situation in Somalia. His overall rationale is “to examine whether or not state failure is a useful and accurate explanation” for this piracy, and he does so through a review of “the history, motivation, organization, criminal methods, and operational tactics of the Somali pirates”. (3) He also explores terrorism as it relates to the maritime world here. While highlighting various attacks, he puts this type of crime into perspective globally. The narrative clearly shows that just because the state has failed doesn’t mean that governing is nonexistent. To round out this assessment, Murphy discusses why legal prosecution of these criminals is such a problem.
After providing a well-rounded investigation into Somalia, Murphy compares this region to that of the Barbary States. This interesting chapter shows the similarities and differences, as well as the lessons that can be learned in studying these two regions and periods. Perhaps the strongest and most succinct paragraph, however, is the closing one in the final chapter. This summary epitomizes what was and is true, not only as regards Somalia, but other regions to come where we must and need to fight piracy.
Review Copyrighted ©2011 Cindy Vallar
- Somalia: A Failed State?
- Somali Piracy: 1989-2006
- Piracy and Fishing
- The Principal Piracy Groups: 1996-2006
- The Attack on the Seabourn Spirit and its Consequences
- A Clan-based Society
- The Barre Dictatorship and its Aftermath
- The Rise and Fall of the TNG and the Rise of the TFG
- Economic Motivation for Turmoil
- Puntland: The Pirate Sanctuary?
- Somalia: Without a Government but not Ungoverned
- The Growth of Political Islam
- The Link to Terrorism
- The Rise of the Islamic Courts Union (ICU)
- The ICU Come to Power
- The ICU’s Fall
- The Return of the Pirate Gangs
- The Consequences of Reward
- Why Piracy Became so Virulent: the Political Dimension
- Why Piracy Became so Profitable: the Organizational Dimension
- Legal Measures
- The Naval Response
- Somali Piracy and Terrorism
- The Further Fall of a Fallen State
- Al-Shabaab and the Growth of Islamism in Southern Somalia
- Somalia and Barbary
Home Pirate Articles Pirate Links Book Reviews Thistles & Pirates
Click on the Cannon to Contact Me